U.S. loses bid to halt children's climate change lawsuit


us
 U.S. loses bid to halt children's climate change lawsuit

A protest in New York against climate change sceptics in Donald Trumps cabinet.A federal appeals court on Wednesday rejected the U.S. government's bid to halt a lawsuit by young people claiming that President Donald Trump and his administration are violating their constitutional rights by ignoring the harms caused by climate change.

By a 3-0 vote, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco said the administration had not met the "high bar" under federal law to dismiss the Oregon lawsuit, which was originally brought in 2015 against the administration of President Barack Obama.

The potentially far-reaching case is one of a handful seeking to have courts address global warming and its causes.

Twenty-one plaintiffs, now aged 10 to 21, accused federal officials and oil industry executives of knowing for decades that carbon dioxide emissions from the burning of fossil fuels destabilize the climate, but refusing to do anything about it.

They said this has deprived them of their due process rights to life, liberty and property, including to live in a habitable climate.

U.S. District Judge Ann Aiken in Eugene, Oregon in November 2016 refused to dismiss the lawsuit, saying a quick dismissal without addressing the merits could sanction the government's alleged "knowing decision to poison the air."

In seeking to overturn that ruling, the government said letting the case proceed could lead to burdensome litigation, and provoke a "constitutional crisis" by pitting courts against Trump and the many other Executive Branch officials named as defendants.

But in Wednesday's decision, Chief Judge Sidney Thomas said the dismissal request was premature, and deciding whether the plaintiffs' claims were too broad could be addressed through the normal legal process.

"Litigation burdens are part of our legal system, and the defendants still have the usual remedies before the district court for nonmeritorious litigation," Thomas wrote. "C1aims and remedies often are vastly narrowed as litigation proceeds; we have no reason to assume this case will be any different."

The U.S. Department of Justice, which handled the government appeal, did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Julia Olson, who represented the plaintiffs and is executive director of Our Children's Trust, which advocates for improving the climate, in an interview welcomed the decision.

"It's very exciting," she said. "It will be the first time that climate science and the federal government's role in creating its dangers will go on trial in a U.S. court."

The lawsuit was returned to Aiken for further proceedings. (Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; Editing by Susan Thomas)

By: Reuters

« us

  CITIES NEWS
LONDON
DUBAI
BEDMINSTER, New Jersey
SEOUL
TAIPEI
MOSCOW
BERLIN
STOCKHOLM
WASHINGTON
LOS ANGELES
BRASILIA
SILVERSTONE, England
SAYLORSBURG, Pa
AMSTERDAM
BERGERAC, France
KABUL
BARCELONA
PARIS
MOSUL, Iraq
BRUSSELS
DOHA
CAIRO
FRANKFURT
LAUSANNE
  DATE NEWS
2018/09/24
Two Former Kavanaugh Classmates Withdraw Names From Statement Disputing Accuser


2018/09/23
Ed Whelan takes leave of absence from Ethics and Public Policy Center after claim Brett Kavanaugh accuser misidentified alleged attacker


2018/09/22
Kavanaugh accuser wants to talk to Senate; terms up in air


2018/09/21
100 Kegs or Bust: Kavanaugh friend has spent years writing about high school debauchery


2018/09/20
China teams up with Russia to aim for 'desirable world order'


2018/09/19
Ford lawyer: GOP plan for Kavanaugh hearing 'not a fair or good faith investigation'